Page 1 of 11 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 107
  1. #1
    Assistant Pro Lazkir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Posts
    196

    Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    I've just read about this happening to poor old Mathew Southgate. Pretty unlucky, and a rule I wasn't aware of.

    But... it did remind me of this incident with Phil Mickelson. I remember watching that live and thinking how unlucky it was then.
    What I don't remember is Phil having to retake the putt, nor being penalised for not doing so.

    Can anyone remember the incident and explain why he wasn't punished in the same way as Mathew Southgate, or have I remembered it wrong and he was forced to retake it?
    Handicap 13.4 Ping G20 Driver MD 3 & 5 Woods Ping G20 Hybrid Ping G20 Irons 5 - U Cleveland RTX Cav 60 degree Wedge Odyssey Works Wide Versa Putter

  2. #2
    Tour Winner
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Edinburgh
    Posts
    2,761

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazkir View Post
    I've just read about this happening to poor old Mathew Southgate. Pretty unlucky, and a rule I wasn't aware of.

    But... it did remind me of this incident with Phil Mickelson. I remember watching that live and thinking how unlucky it was then.
    What I don't remember is Phil having to retake the putt, nor being penalised for not doing so.

    Can anyone remember the incident and explain why he wasn't punished in the same way as Mathew Southgate, or have I remembered it wrong and he was forced to retake it?
    I don't recollect the Mickelson incident but there are different outcomes to your ball being deflected by a leaf depending on whether the leaf was motionless at the time or moving. If your ball is deflected by an outside agency such as a loose impediment that is motionless, you play the ball from where it ends up without penalty. That applies anywhere on the course. If your ball is played from the putting green and is deflected by a moving outside agency, you must replay the stroke. [Rule 19-1]

  3. #3
    Assistant Pro Lazkir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Posts
    196

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    That would explain it. The Mickleson one had stopped moving when his ball hit it, whereas the other was in motion.

    Thanks
    Handicap 13.4 Ping G20 Driver MD 3 & 5 Woods Ping G20 Hybrid Ping G20 Irons 5 - U Cleveland RTX Cav 60 degree Wedge Odyssey Works Wide Versa Putter

  4. #4
    Tour Winner Maninblack4612's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    South Shields
    Posts
    3,045

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    I don't have a lot of sympathy with Matthew Southgate. He's a professional & should know the basic rules or at least be aware of situations where he needs to check. It probably cost him 5 strokes, not 4.

    The 2 strokes for signing an incorrect card is just stupid, the retrospective penalty should be enough.
    Taylormade M1 9˝°, Matrix Black Tie 6M3 Regular
    Taylormade SLDR 3 wood
    Taylormade SLDR 5 wood
    TaylormadeSLDR Rescue 22°
    Mizuno JPX850 forged irons 4 - PW
    Titelist Vokey 50 & 58 wedges
    Odyssey Metal X No. 1,Ping Anser Redwood, Ping Anser blade (1960s vintage) (depending on how they behave)
    Vice Pro Plus ball
    H/C 9 @ ssgc.co.uk

  5. #5
    Grand Slam Winner Imurg's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Aylesbury Bucks
    Posts
    22,399

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    Quote Originally Posted by Maninblack4612 View Post
    I don't have a lot of sympathy with Matthew Southgate. He's a professional & should know the basic rules
    Just my sixpence worth but I wouldn't consider this a 'basic' rule...I've been playing 25+ years and have a decent grasp of the rules - I've never heard of this one and the talk on Twitter last night suggests a good few more, including several Pros, didn't either...
    So it all depends on whether the leaf was moving or not....
    Talk about complicating things. We're going to need to video every putt just in case a leaf blows across, stops for 0.1 of a millisecond then moves again...
    What happened to Rub of the Green..?
    Epic 10°
    Big Bertha 3w 15°
    Big Bertha 5w 19°
    Big Bertha 4h 22°
    Launcher 5h 26°
    Legacy Black V 6-PW
    X 50/12
    MD2 54/14 , 58/14c
    ProType 2-Ball/TT3

    Handicap 7.7 at Whipsnade Park

    You might be a King or a Little Street Sweeper but sooner or later you dance with The Reaper...

  6. #6
    Challenge Tour Pro
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Yeovil
    Posts
    716

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    I consider myself to have an above average knowledge of the rules but only found out this one last year.

    I would not consider it to be a 'basic rule' which the vast majority of payers would be aware of.

    I would agree with the point about a Pro needing to check with a rules official before continuing though.

  7. #7
    Journeyman Pro
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    2,479

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    I wonder if this rule would be better for all if they changed the 'must' be replaced to 'can' be?

  8. #8
    Money List Winner Slab's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    Port Louis
    Posts
    5,182

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    Quote Originally Posted by woody69 View Post
    I wonder if this rule would be better for all if they changed the 'must' be replaced to 'can' be?
    This is what i was thinking, then replaying or finishing would be up to the player and the field is not disadvantaged as far as I can see

  9. #9
    Grand Slam Winner Imurg's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Aylesbury Bucks
    Posts
    22,399

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    You could the scenario where a player has a tricky, multi break putt of, say, 50ft...
    3 inches from the hole a leaf deflects it away from the hole...stroke to be replayed and the player has a really good idea of the line...
    Epic 10°
    Big Bertha 3w 15°
    Big Bertha 5w 19°
    Big Bertha 4h 22°
    Launcher 5h 26°
    Legacy Black V 6-PW
    X 50/12
    MD2 54/14 , 58/14c
    ProType 2-Ball/TT3

    Handicap 7.7 at Whipsnade Park

    You might be a King or a Little Street Sweeper but sooner or later you dance with The Reaper...

  10. #10
    Money List Winner paddyk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    6,518

    Re: Leaf deflecting putt. New rule?

    Quote Originally Posted by Imurg View Post
    You could the scenario where a player has a tricky, multi break putt of, say, 50ft...
    3 inches from the hole a leaf deflects it away from the hole...stroke to be replayed and the player has a really good idea of the line...
    Sounds like he already had a good idea of the line.
    COYS

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Latest Golf News

Quiz Of The Week – 20th October

Test your knowledge of this week in golf with our latest quiz!

October 20, 2017

American Golf Deals: The Best Current Offers

We check out the best deal that retailer American Golf currently have on their site

October 20, 2017

Amazon Golf Deals – The Best Current Offers

Amazon is an incredible place to buy anything of course, but the golf section on the website is a great place to find some goodies for your game

October 20, 2017

Five Of The Best Clifftop Golf Courses

Our historic links are the lifeblood and roots of golf, but clifftop courses offer a coastal contrast that is often even more dramatic

October 20, 2017

7 Things We Expected In 2017 That Didn’t Happen

It's been a year of surprises in 2017, Rory didn't win a fifth major and Matsuyama didn't reach the world #1 spot

October 19, 2017