Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 24

Thread: Rules query

  1. #1

    Rules query

    Could someone explain to me why this situation is a penalty.

    I hit a drive into the semi rough which was a bit wet, when I proceeded to take my second shot I didn't connect right and the ball buried a few inches from where I hit. I think I've only done this twice before and that was years ago and I'm sure I can remember from then it is a penalty so I played 4 for my next shot.

    I just can't understand why this is a penalty, what's the difference between this situation than having a drive plug off the fairway and being allowed a drop?

    No doubt there is a reasonable explanation so will be interested to hear from the experts.

    Btw this happened twice to me yesterday and it was a comp.

  2. #2

    Re: Rules query

    Maybe one of the mods need to move this to the rules section

  3. #3
    Major Champion Foxholer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    Wasting away again in Margaritaville
    Posts
    17,824

    Re: Rules query

    Doesn't seem to be a penalty to me! Unless when you 'didn't connect right' you hit it more than once.

    Or (more likely imo) you THEN decided to declare it unplayable and take a (penalty) drop within 2 club lengths not nearer the hole.

    Balls 'plugged in closely mown area' (ie fairway length) are covered under Rule 25-2 (Embedded Ball). It would need a Local Rule to apply for 'Plugged in the Rough' to be allowed without penalty.
    Adams Speedline 9.5* Tech Rul 54 S
    Adams XTD TI 15* set to 13.5* Matrix Red Tie 70R
    Adams XTD TI 15* set to 16.5* Matrix Red Tie 70S
    Adams XTD TI 20* at 21* Matrix Red Tie S
    Adams XTD TI 23* at 24* Matrix Red Tie S
    Titleist 913 27* Diamana Kuro Kage S
    McGregor PCB Tour 6-PW S300
    Cleveland 588 Forged 52, 58
    Seemore Si1 33" or Bettinardi Baby Bee CS 33"

    Ia Ora Te Natura
    E Mea Arofa Teie Ao Nei

  4. #4

    Re: Rules query

    Quote Originally Posted by Foxholer View Post
    Doesn't seem to be a penalty to me! Unless when you 'didn't connect right' you hit it more than once.

    Or (more likely imo) you THEN decided to declare it unplayable and take a (penalty) drop within 2 club lengths not nearer the hole.

    Balls 'plugged in closely mown area' (ie fairway length) are covered under Rule 25-2 (Embedded Ball). It would need a Local Rule to apply for 'Plugged in the Rough' to be allowed without penalty.
    I didn't hit it more than once.

    I didn't declare it unplayable.

    We have a local rule for balls plugged in rough.

    I was told this was a penalty by more than one member of our club so never looked up the ruling myself.

    Maybe they were wrong.

  5. #5
    Ryder Cup Winner patricks148's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Highlands
    Posts
    12,936

    Re: Rules query

    Quote Originally Posted by Rlburnside View Post
    I didn't hit it more than once.

    I didn't declare it unplayable.

    We have a local rule for balls plugged in rough.

    I was told this was a penalty by more than one member of our club so never looked up the ruling myself.

    Maybe they were wrong.
    what was the penalty for then?

    never heard of one for a shot not hit right before??? harsh
    http://www.nairngolfclub.co.uk/

    The Nairn Golf Club, Club Champion (handicap) 2017

  6. #6
    Major Champion Foxholer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    Wasting away again in Margaritaville
    Posts
    17,824

    Re: Rules query

    Quote Originally Posted by Rlburnside View Post
    I didn't hit it more than once.

    I didn't declare it unplayable.

    We have a local rule for balls plugged in rough.

    I was told this was a penalty by more than one member of our club so never looked up the ruling myself.

    Maybe they were wrong.
    Doh! I daftly 'missed' the 'semi' in your OP! So ignore my 'Doesn't seem...' etc in my reply! I believe i can see why the Penalty may have been required

    The ruling about whether you are entitled to free relief. or whether relief is under penalty, would depend on the wording of the LR, but if it's as per the example in the Appendix, then there's certainly cause to believe that it's under penalty! This is because free relief is only available when 'it is in its own pitch-mark'. Pitch-mark isn't defined, but a ball that is simply badly struck, so embeds, wouldn't seem to qualify for as Embedded (under the Note to the LR - as per Note 1 of 25-2).

    In fact, Decision 25-2/6 seems to be the equivalent of what may have happened (though probably on closely mown area).

    Sorry about misleading you earlier if that is what actually happened! Was it? As in 'Did the ball ever become airborne?'
    Last edited by Foxholer; 27-Aug-2017 at 14:27.
    Adams Speedline 9.5* Tech Rul 54 S
    Adams XTD TI 15* set to 13.5* Matrix Red Tie 70R
    Adams XTD TI 15* set to 16.5* Matrix Red Tie 70S
    Adams XTD TI 20* at 21* Matrix Red Tie S
    Adams XTD TI 23* at 24* Matrix Red Tie S
    Titleist 913 27* Diamana Kuro Kage S
    McGregor PCB Tour 6-PW S300
    Cleveland 588 Forged 52, 58
    Seemore Si1 33" or Bettinardi Baby Bee CS 33"

    Ia Ora Te Natura
    E Mea Arofa Teie Ao Nei

  7. #7
    Ryder Cup Winner
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Central Scotland
    Posts
    11,290

    Re: Rules query

    It would only be a penalty if you have to declare it unplayable but as your club have a local rule covering plugged balls in the rough then I don't see why you wouldn't get a free drop

  8. #8

    Re: Rules query

    Quote Originally Posted by Foxholer View Post
    Doh! I daftly 'missed' the 'semi' in your OP! So ignore my 'Doesn't seem...' etc in my reply! I believe i can see why the Penalty may have been required

    The ruling about whether you are entitled to free relief. or whether relief is under penalty, would depend on the wording of the LR, but if it's as per the example in the Appendix, then there's certainly cause to believe that it's under penalty! This is because free relief is only available when 'it is in its own pitch-mark'. Pitch-mark isn't defined, but a ball that is simply badly struck, so embeds, wouldn't seem to qualify for as Embedded (under the Note to the LR - as per Note 1 of 25-2).

    In fact, Decision 25-2/6 seems to be the equivalent of what may have happened (though probably on closely mown area).

    Sorry about misleading you earlier if that is what actually happened! Was it? As in 'Did the ball ever become airborne?'
    No the ball was certainly never airborn, thanks for your explanation I think I understand the reason why it's a penalty now ie ball wasn't it its own pitch mark but badly struck and embedded which doesn't qualify as embedded!!!

    Glad I was right in calling a penalty on myself, although I think it's very harsh.

  9. #9
    Ryder Cup Winner Region3's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Leicester
    Posts
    12,190

    Re: Rules query

    Did you play the ball from the "buried" position?

  10. #10

    Re: Rules query

    Quote Originally Posted by Region3 View Post
    Did you play the ball from the "buried" position?
    Yes, dropped ball and added penalty playing my 4th shot

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Latest Golf News

Tour Championship Golf Betting Tips

The finale of the 2017 PGA Tour season happens at East Lake Golf Club check out who we think will do well with these Tour Championship Golf Betting Tips

September 19, 2017

Portugal Masters Golf Betting Tips

The European Tour is getting towards the end of the season, check out who the GM Tipster has picked to do well with these Portugal Masters Golf Betting Tips

September 19, 2017

Quiz Of The Week 15th September

How much have you been paying attention to the golfing world this week? Test your knowledge with our quiz...

September 19, 2017

FedEx Cup to be decided at Tour Championship

The 2017 FedEx Cup culminates this week at the Tour Championship at East Lake in Georgia. Jordan Spieth leads the rankings but any of the players in the top five on the standings will claim the Cup if they win at East Lake.

September 19, 2017

Padraig Harrington defends Portugal Masters

Padraig Harrington defends the Portugal Masters over the Dom Pedro Victoria Golf Course in Vilamoura and a strong field has assembled for the tournament.

September 19, 2017